Beyond research
Cafés and me
On whether going to cafés counts as a hobby, and what I am actually there for.
A hobby that felt odd to say out loud
When people ask what I do for fun, the honest answer is that I go to cafés. For a long time I felt uneasy saying it. Writing and drawing produce something. Reading and visiting exhibitions take something in. Going to cafés looked like plain consumption: I pay, I sit, I leave with nothing.
The more I looked at that distinction, the less it held. An exhibition needs a ticket and a book has a price, so those are consumption too. They only feel respectable because there is obvious content to absorb. What bothered me about cafés was not the paying. It was that they seemed to have no content and nothing that adds up over time.
Robert Stebbins separates serious leisure, where skill and knowledge build up, from casual leisure, which is simply enjoyed. Café-going can be either. Some people learn to tell roasts and origins apart, or read how a room handles light and movement. I am mostly on the casual side, and I have stopped thinking that needs an apology.
Like going to the beach
The comparison that settled it for me was the beach, or the mountains. Nobody finds it strange when someone says they like going to the sea, although that produces nothing either. You go to be inside a certain atmosphere for a while.
There is one difference. The atmosphere of a coast is not made by anyone; I go there to meet it. The atmosphere of a café is designed: the lighting, the music, the height of the chairs, what the window frames. Going from café to café is a little like walking through atmospheres that people have curated one by one, which is probably why I keep wanting to try a new place.
So I no longer force the word “hobby” onto it. “I like spending time in cafés with a good atmosphere” is as ordinary a sentence as “I like walking by the sea.”
What I take in is atmosphere
Gernot Böhme gave me words for this. He describes atmosphere as something in between: it is not a property of any chair or lamp, and it is not only my mood projected onto the room. Someone else who walks in feels it as well. Before I have looked at the furniture, my body already knows whether the place is loose or tense, cold or warm. One yellow lamp can tune a whole corner.
Böhme is also critical. He points out that more and more of what we buy is staged mood, and cafés are a clear case. I accept that. Going to cafés is consumption. But what I consume is real, and it can only be had by being there in person. It is input, only not in the form of text: light, how dense the sound is, the taste of the drink, the pace of the people around me.
Tasting, not settling
The humanistic geographers look at a longer stretch of time. For Yi-Fu Tuan, space is movement and place is pause: a space becomes a place once you have stopped there often enough for experience and feeling to gather. Edward Relph describes a range from passing through as an outsider to belonging somewhere. David Seamon writes about the “place ballet,” when many people’s routines cross at the same spot: the same barista every morning, the old man who always takes the window seat.
Read this way, visiting many cafés and having one café are different experiences. When I go somewhere new I am tasting an atmosphere, which needs no history. Returning to the same table twenty times is what turns a shop into my place. I do far more of the first, and it helped to admit that. I am wandering more than I am putting down roots.
Not everyone is working
I used to dislike co-working cafés, and it took me a while to see why. What I like about an ordinary café is that not everyone there is working. Some people talk, some read, some stare out of the window, some type. No single state is the default, so I can move between working and resting without either one feeling out of place. In a room where everybody is working, resting starts to feel like a mismatch with the room.
Being left alone is part of it. Erving Goffman called this civil inattention: strangers give each other a brief glance that says “I see you,” then look away to say “and I will not intrude.” He compared it to dimming your headlights for an oncoming car. It is a courtesy, not coldness. In a café I am present among other people and I owe none of them a reply. That is a large part of why I can relax there.
A ticket to talk
The same courtesy makes it hard to start a conversation, because breaking it needs a reason. One day in late October I spent time in a shared space that had been curated, and I changed my mind about such places. It offered something an ordinary café rarely does: a chance to meet people.
Harvey Sacks has a phrase for what was missing before, a “ticket to talk.” Strangers need something that makes opening their mouths reasonable: a shared activity, a topic, a thing to point at and ask, “Are you here for this too?” Ordinary cafés have plenty of people. What they lack is the ticket. A curated space hands one to everybody through its theme, its events, or the people it brings together.
This comes at a cost. Ray Oldenburg’s third place, the informal gathering spot that is neither home nor work, is supposed to be neutral ground where status is levelled and anyone may walk in. A curated space makes meeting easy by selecting who is in the room. It is closer to a community than to a third place: easier to enter into conversation, less open, and less forgiving of someone who only wants to sit there unnoticed.
The two preferences do not contradict each other. One is about what the atmosphere lets me do, the other about which encounters the space makes possible. When I want to drift between work and daydreaming, I go to an ordinary café for its atmosphere. When I want to meet someone, I now know to look for a place that gives out tickets.
What I have not worked out
I still do not know what made that October encounter happen. It could have been the activity, the way the room was arranged, such as one long shared table, or the fact that the people there already had something in common. The answer would tell me what “curating” a space really curates: the room, the programme, or the people. I will keep going to cafés to find out.
I post the cafés I visit on Threads at @wpbag.cafe.
Reading behind this
- Gernot Böhme on atmosphere and the aesthetic economy
- Yi-Fu Tuan, Space and Place and Topophilia
- Edward Relph, Place and Placelessness
- David Seamon on body ballet and place ballet
- Ray Oldenburg, The Great Good Place
- Erving Goffman, Behavior in Public Places
- Harvey Sacks on the ticket to talk
- Robert Stebbins on serious and casual leisure